top of page

Car Rental Miami to Key West: The Convertible Road Trip Done Right This Holiday Season

2 days ago
7 min read

There's a moment, somewhere past Marathon, when the land just gives up. The mangroves fall away, the road lifts onto the Seven Mile Bridge, and for a few minutes it's only you, the open road and two shades of blue water on either side. Top down. Sun on your shoulders. Nobody talking, because nobody needs to.


That's why people fly across an ocean to make this drive. And it's why your car rental from Miami to Key West matters more than almost any other rental decision you'll make on a Florida trip. The car isn't just how you get there. On the Overseas Highway, the car is the experience.


December is one of the best months to do it. The air is softer, the light is golden, and the Keys are dressed for the holidays. Here's how we'd plan it, stop by stop, and which convertible we'd hand you the keys to.


Car Rental Miami to Key West: The Holiday Convertible Drive

Why December Is the Sweet Spot for the Miami to Key West Road Trip


Summer here is hot and stormy in the afternoons. December flips the script. Average highs in Key West sit around the mid-to-upper 70s for most of the month, which is exactly the temperature a convertible was built for.


Bonus: sunset comes early. In Key West, the sun sets between roughly 5:37 p.m. at the start of the month and 5:49 p.m. at the end. Leave Miami in the morning, take your time on the stops, and roll into Key West in time for sunset at Mallory Square.


The holiday season also brings the Keys' own brand of festive. Key West's Lighted Boat Parade is scheduled for Saturday, December 12, 2026, at the Historic Seaport, with festivities starting around 6 p.m. and the parade at about 8 p.m. If your dates line up, it's a very good reason to stay the night.


On the Overseas Highway, the car isn't how you get there. The car is the experience.

The Route: What Your Car Rental from Miami to Key West Will Actually Cover

The full drive from Miami to Key West is about 160 miles and takes roughly three and a half to four hours without stops. Nobody does it without stops, and nobody should.


The route has two parts. First, the mainland stretch: most drivers take the Homestead Extension of Florida's Turnpike south to Florida City. Then the good part begins. The Overseas Highway, U.S. 1, runs 113 miles from Key Largo to Key West and crosses 42 bridges along the way.


Two quick navigation tips:


  • Follow the mile markers. Small green signs on the shoulder count down as you head south, ending at mile marker 0 in Key West.

  • Bayside vs. oceanside. Addresses in the Keys are often listed as "bayside" or "oceanside." It tells you which side of U.S. 1 to look on.


The Stops We'd Make (and Where to Slow Down)


Key Largo: Your First Taste of the Keys

Key Largo is the first island you'll reach, roughly mile markers 106 to 90. John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park is here, and it's the classic first stop for anyone who wants a look at the reef by glass-bottom boat or snorkel. Short on time? Grab a coffee and keep rolling. The best is still ahead.


Islamorada: Tarpon, Art and a Long Lunch

Islamorada calls itself the sportfishing capital of the world, and you'll feel it the minute you pull in. Our favorite pit stop is Robbie's of Islamorada at mile marker 77.5. You can walk the dock and feed the wild tarpon, browse the open-air market of local art and jewelry, and have a long, lazy lunch looking at the water. Watch your bucket of fish. The pelicans have opinions.


Marathon and the Seven Mile Bridge

This is the stretch you'll remember. Just past Marathon, the Seven Mile Bridge carries you out over open water, with the old bridge running alongside like a ghost of the railroad era. Let your passenger take the photos.


If you want to experience it on foot, the Old Seven Mile Bridge reopened as a walking and biking path. It's a 2.2-mile span out to tiny Pigeon Key, with parking just past Knights Key Boulevard. Even a short walk out gets you the view.


Somewhere past Marathon, the land just gives up. That's the moment you came for. 

Bahia Honda State Park: The Best Beach on the Drive

At mile marker 37, Bahia Honda State Park is the beach stop most people wish they'd planned for. A short trail leads up to what's left of the old Bahia Honda Bridge, and the view from the top is one of the best in the Keys. The park has three beaches: Calusa Beach is the calmest and best for families, Sandspur Beach is the biggest, and Loggerhead Beach is known for shallow, clear water.


Key West: Sunset, Duval and Mile Marker 0

Park the car, walk Old Town, and time your evening around the nightly Sunset Celebration at Mallory Square, where street performers, food carts and half the island gather every late afternoon to watch the sun go down. Then go find a slice of key lime pie. That part isn't optional.


The Convertible We'd Pick for This Drive

Here's where we get honest, because the right car for this trip comes down to one thing most rental counters never explain: miles.


A round trip from Miami to Key West is roughly 320 miles before you add a single detour, sunset loop or beach run. So mileage policy matters.


Our Pick: The Mustang Convertible

If we're handing you keys for the Keys, it's the Mustang Convertible. Here's why:


  • Unlimited miles. Drive down, drive around, drive back. No math, no meter-watching.

  • Four seats. Room for a couple and their bags, or a small group who packs light.

  • One-touch power soft top. Top down for the bridges, top up in seconds if a passing shower rolls through.

  • 21+ to rent, with a $300 security deposit that's released the same day you return the car.


We run the largest Mustang convertible fleet in Florida, and when you book a Mustang Convertible with us, a Mustang Convertible is waiting.

Model guaranteed · color based on availability.

Want More Power? Know the Mileage Math First

The Mustang GT Convertible, Corvette C8 Convertible and Porsche Boxster are a blast on the Overseas Highway, and we'd never talk you out of one. Just know that each includes 150 miles per day. Additional miles are charged at $1 to $4 per mile depending on the length of your rental.


What that means in practice:


  • A same-day round trip in one of these cars covers about 320 miles against a 150-mile allowance. On a 1-day rental, every additional mile is $4, even if it's only one mile over. That adds up fast.

  • Stay a couple of nights and the allowance grows with every rental day, which makes the math far friendlier for a down-and-back trip.

  • On a 7-day rental, you get a combined allowance of 1,050 miles (150 miles x 7 days), and any miles over that are $1 each.


Our honest advice: if you're doing Key West in a day, take the Mustang Convertible. If you're staying a few nights and want the GT, the C8 or the Boxster, go for it with your eyes open.


Traveling as a Group of Four or Five?

Our Jeep Wrangler and Jeep Sahara are both 4-door, seat five, and come with unlimited miles. The Wrangler has a manual soft top and is 21+. The Sahara adds a one-touch power top, leather seats and integrated GPS, and is 23+.


If you're doing Key West in a day, take the Mustang. Unlimited miles means no math, just the drive. 

Holiday Driving Tips for the Overseas Highway

December is busy season in the Keys, and U.S. 1 is two lanes for long stretches. A little planning helps:


  • Leave early. A morning start means calmer roads and more time at the stops.

  • Avoid holiday-weekend Friday afternoons heading south if you can. Everyone else has the same idea.

  • Pack for the top-down life. Sunglasses, a hat, sunscreen and a light layer for the drive home after dark.

  • Watch the speed limits. They change often along the islands.


SunPass and Tolls on the Way Down

The tolls on this trip are on the mainland side. The Homestead Extension of Florida's Turnpike is a cashless toll road, and if you take the Card Sound Road shortcut into Key Largo, that bridge is cashless too. Tolls are billed automatically: you pay the actual tolls you use, plus a $5 per day service fee that's capped at $15 (the cap applies to the fee only). Most guests choose to prepay SunPass when they book, so there's nothing to settle afterward and nothing deducted from the security deposit.


Picking Up Your Car Rental from Miami to Key West

You can start your road trip from any of our five pickup locations: our Miami Beach HQ, Downtown Miami, Brickell, Miami International Airport (MIA) or Fort Lauderdale Airport (FLL). Paperwork is done before you arrive, so pickup takes minutes, not hours.


Flying into MIA or FLL? Grab the car and point it south.



The Overseas Highway Is Waiting


Book the convertible you actually want for the drive to Key West. Paperwork done before you land, no lines, no surprises.



Model guaranteed · color based on availability.

Car Rental Miami to Key West: The Holiday Convertible Drive

Frequently Asked Questions


How far is the drive from Miami to Key West?

The drive from Miami to Key West is about 160 miles each way and takes roughly three and a half to four hours without stops. Most people take most of a day with stops in Key Largo, Islamorada, Marathon and Bahia Honda. The Overseas Highway portion runs 113 miles from Key Largo to Key West and crosses 42 bridges.


What is the best car rental from Miami to Key West?

For most travelers, we recommend the Mustang Convertible. It includes unlimited miles, seats four and has a one-touch power soft top, so a 320-mile round trip costs you nothing extra in mileage. Groups of four or five can choose our 4-door Jeep Wrangler or Jeep Sahara, which also come with unlimited miles.


Can I drive a Corvette or Porsche to Key West?

Yes. The Corvette C8, Porsche Boxster and Mustang GT include 150 miles per day, with additional miles at $1 to $4 per mile depending on rental length. A same-day round trip goes well over the daily allowance, so these cars make the most sense when you stay a few nights in the Keys.


Are there tolls between Miami and Key West?

The tolls are on the mainland side. The Homestead Extension of Florida's Turnpike is a cashless toll road, and the Card Sound Road bridge into Key Largo is also cashless. Tolls are billed automatically: you pay the actual tolls plus a $5 per day service fee capped at $15, and most guests prepay SunPass when they book.


Is December a good time to drive to Key West?

December is one of the best months for the drive. Average highs in Key West run in the mid-to-upper 70s, perfect for top-down driving, and sunset falls between about 5:37 and 5:49 p.m. It's also busy season, so leave early, avoid holiday-weekend Friday afternoons heading south and book your Key West stay ahead.


 
 
 

Comments


© 2013 All rights reserved Miami Convertibles Car Rental LLC

Miami Convertibles Car rental.png

📞 Contact Miami Convertibles Car Rental

Let's Get You in the Driver’s Seat!

​

Got Questions? We’ve Got Answers 

📧 Email us: info@MiamiConvertibles.com

📱 Call us: +1 (305)799-7892

💬 WhatsApp: Chat with us

🚗 Book Now or Peek at our Rates

📣 Follow Us: Facebook | Instagram

🌟 Read Our Reviews: Check out what our customers are saying on Google

bottom of page